
Leave aside the notion of whether this is the world maligning Pakistan or Pakistan maligning Pakistan (the allegations emanated largely from Pakistan circles). It seems incredulous that Pakistan would do this, if assumed they did it indeed. Here’s why.
Pakistan would not have dropped the match against New Zealand because
It is the ICC Champions Trophy semi final, duh?
Who would want to lose the semi final and not get into the final, especially if there was the possibility of a double with the 2009 ICC World Twenty20 in England?
Younis Khan, the Pakistan captain, could not have dropped the catch off Grant Elliot deliberately because
Refer to the above answer, but also because Shahid Afridi is breathing down his neck and Younis Khan has always wanted to lead a successful Pakistan team and every one knows, catches win matches!
Umar Gul could not be involved in ball tampering in South Africa because
Although Gul was cleared of the malpractice alleged by New Zealand in the 2009 ICC World Twenty20, it is even more less likely that he or anyone of the Pakistan team would be picking the seam on the occasion against Australia in the final league match because if Jamshed Ahmed Dasti’s allegation (he is the Chairman of the Sports Committee of the Pakistan National Assembly...phew!) that Pakistan wanted Australia to win the match to keep India out of the tournament, where was the need to pick the seam? Australia had to win, right?
Pakistan would not throw away the tournament because
Pakistan has become the less favoured tourist destination for cricket teams and the only way Pakistan could show the world that there is a need to respect cricket in Pakistan despite the turmoil is by showing that they have not lost their competitiveness by any manner or means or their confidence dented by lack of teams agreeing to tour Pakistan.
What could be a stronger statement than winning the tournament?
Pakistan could not have conspired against India because
Leave aside Indo Pak diplomatic relations or even of Pakistan seeking a revenge of sorts for India cancelling their tour to Pakistan earlier this year over the terror attacks of 26/11 on Mumbai last year.
Simple cricket logic would have stated that Pakistan would have benefitted allowing the weaker team (no disrespect to India) to get through, Pakistan would have stood a greater chance of beating India had they made it to the final rather than having to face Australia, which New Zealand denied them, of course.
A strong, in form Pakistan team against a clueless Indian captain, Mahendra Singh Dhoni, with an injured cast team of performers. Now would that not have told the story?
(Disclaimer: If money was the sole criteria, then all the cricket logic simply goes out of the window)
Allegations of a Truant Pakistan from Inside and Out
Australia ICC Champions Trophy Winners in Pictures
CT Final: Australia Clinch Trophy in Watson’s Second Century Burst
CT Final: New Zealand Whimper in Setting Target
Allegations of Pakistan’s Ball Tampering Resurface
Pictures of a Crest Fallen Pakistan
CT Semi Final 2: New Zealand, Elliot Score Past Pakistan
CT Semi Final 1: England Succumb to Ponting, Watson Centuries
CT Eng v Aus Half Time: England Resurrected; But Is It Enough to Hurt Australia?
South Africa Searching for Answers, Specialists, Hypnotists Perhaps?
Bresnan Blows His Top Lid, Flower Seals it Shut
Ravi Shastri Vents Ire on Indian Selectors
CT Semi Final 1 Fifteen Overs: Australia Have the Mark on England
Akram Makes it to Hall of Fame, But Shame for Dhoni
WC Grace: Latest Entrant to ICC’s Hall of Fame!
Strauss Slams Smith, Applauds Vettori
ICC Champions Trophy Semi Finals Face Off!
CT India Beat WI, But Was Anyone Interested?
India’s fortunes Mistimed: Sachin Out!
CT Pak v Aus: Aussie-Pak Thriller Denies India Even a Slim Chance
CT NZ v Eng: New Zealand Stampede England for Semi Final spot
CT Ind v Aus Rain Break: Game Gone With the Wind, Really!
Cheerleaders Of Another Encounter
Super Sunday Turns to Sorrow Day for SA Cricket, ICC Champions Trophy
CT Eng v SL: Hosts Out of Tournament But Not Because of Smith
CT Ind V Aus Preview: Dhoni Resigned to Losing Toss
CT Eng v SA: South Africa Have to Climb Higher To Get to Table Mountain
CT NZ V SL Full Time: New Zealand Complete Day’s Heroics
CT SL V NZ Half Time: Injured Ryder Raises Team; NZ Win Could make it Interesting
CT Ind V Pak Full Time: India Lose Grip, Pakistan Have Their Revenge
CT Ind V Pak Half Time: Mallik Century Takes Pakistan to Strong Total
CT Aus v WI Full Time: West Indies Nearly Run Australia Out
CT Aus V WI Half Time: Johnson Destroys Windies’ Effort
CT Ind V Pak Preview: Pak Win Toss, Elect to Bat First
CT Eng v SL Full Time: Collingwood Answers Critics with Match Winning Effort
CT New Zealand news: Oram Out, Franklin Called in
CT Ind v Pak: A Rare Clash on the Cards, What Do the Cards Foretell?
CT AUS v WI Preview: Bracken , Clarke Out, Ponting Worries for Future
Champions League Twenty20 Schedule
Champions League Twenty20: Teams Line Up For Feast
CT Eng v SL Half Time: England Bowlers Batter Sri Lanka
Kirsten Says Not Me, It was Paddy Upton
CT Sa V NZ Full Time: AB de Villiers Steers SA to Points Table
CT SA v NZ: Parnell, Van Der Merwe Peg New Zealand Progress
South African Murmurs About Centurion
CT PAK v WI Full Time: WI Bowlers Put Pak Under Duress
Yuvraj, Younis: Broken Fingers Across Borders
CT PAK v WI Half Time: Pak Bowlers Enjoy Workout
Kirsten’s Mantra for India: Sex!
India Have Yuvraj Singh on Serious Injury List
ICC Champions Trophy Points Table and News in the Run Up
CT PAK v WI Preview: Shahid’s Moment to Shine
CT SA v SL Full Time: Hosts Suffer Shock Defeat
CT SA v SL Half Time: Hosts Face Stiff Target
CT SA v SL Preview: SA Want Good Start, Despite Losing Gibbs
Rahul Slams Preparations, Defies Fears After Loss
CT Teams Group B-South Africa Want it More Than Any One Else